Okay first off I never review shoes, restaurants, clothes, etc but I thought I would help someone out with this descriptive review. These shoes are so cute in person and I am just obsessed. I range between 8.5-9 with shoes. But definitely a solid 8.5 I would say. My physical foot fits perfectly in this shoe, the only negative is the strap that's not near your toes but the bridge of your foot is a little loose on me. This might be the fit/style of the shoe which is totally fine, I just wish it was a tad more snug. I think if I got an 8 I would have a bit of my heel hanging off--but not fully sure. Overall I LOVE and you need these shoes.