Rated 1 out of 5 by Dianeb64 from Disappointed I had been yearning for the Penny boot in grey for quite some time and finally ordered them. I was so frustrated with the fit- I wish I had taken a photo of the issue. I wear a size 12 and have a normal size calf (15”). These boots were so big around at the top of the boot- 20”- but were not a wide calf boot. Their explanation was that the calf measurement was that big because of the shoe size. This makes no sense because my sister has the same boot in another color in same size and the top measurement is 16 1/2”. I asked Sam Edelman for an explanation and didn’t get any response.
Date published: 2019-06-13
Rated 1 out of 5 by youl from straight garbage i bought the exact same pair that i had tried on that my mom had and when i received them they were much larger i then ordered a smaller pair and they came in with a completely different color than the first pair-i have both side by side to compare will be returning both and buying different boots extremely disappointed
Date published: 2019-01-19
Rated 1 out of 5 by christina08 from Weird Fit/ Feels Cheap I returned this boot! I normally love my Sam Edelman's but the fit was awkward, really tight in some spots but my foot still slid around like the shoe was big on me. I usually have no problem with sizing either. Also, with the zipper being in the back, I feel like it would break easily with thicker socks etc.
Date published: 2018-12-19
Rated 1 out of 5 by Customer from Avoid Narrow boot Very narrow footbed and calf. I had to return because I could not even zip up the boot. I don't normally ever have to buy a wide calf boot. I also accidentally ordered two pairs (looked like first order didn't go through) and have only received the refund for one of them. They acknowledged them as received on 11/09 - it's been over the ten days timeframe you promised and I'm waiting, Sam Edelman. Tried ordering the wide calf, half size up and they were too long and the calf was too big. I just couldn't win with these boots and returned the last pair too. Not planning on ordering from Sam Edelman website again because the sizing is weird and the customer service was virtually no help when I called in to find the status of my return
Date published: 2018-11-20
Rated 4 out of 5 by Ethel22 from Good Fit, Color is off The color online does not match product received - it is a lot lighter in person. I do wish the boot was darker, but I don't hate the color I received.I am very happy with the styling and shape of the boot. The foot is a little tight and narrow but will work fine. I like the zipper to make it easy to get the boot on and off.
Date published: 2018-11-08
Rated 1 out of 5 by tobi from I’m too short I’m not sure if I’m too short, or the boots are too tall, but these were very uncomfortable to sit in. The top of them dug into the backs of my thighs. For reference, I’m 5’ 2.5”. Otherwise I loved them! But I had to send them back.
Date published: 2018-10-19
Rated 5 out of 5 by jen42 from Great Fall Staple These boots are the perfect classic riding boot. They are comfortable and the heel height is good for everyday wear. The extra details like the snap in the back make them just a bit more interesting. They fit true to size
Date published: 2018-10-12
Rated 3 out of 5 by Julia from Great boots, need a 13! I LOVE these boots. They're beautiful and fit fairly true to size. But I do have unfortunately large, flat feet and need room to fit custom insoles in my shoes. I ordered the first pair in a size 12, my usual size with most shoes. I tried them on without my insoles first and they were a great fit, so if you're a true 12 they're perfect. But they really don't too much wiggle room if you need it. For some odd reason, they do offer this boot in a 13 but only in a wide calf. I figured with free shipping, why not try exchanging them just to see. I tried them on this morning and while they fit my feet perfectly with my insoles, my skinny little calves swim in the extra 2 inches that come with the wide calf. I'll have to return them and continue my search for the perfect fall boot, unless by some miracle someone important sees this review. Tldr: Order these boots. The shipping's free to try them out but you're going to love them anyway unless you are a disproportioned weirdo like me.
Date published: 2018-09-11